Fort Worth

FortWorthWeekly.news — Western roots. Neighborhood news for modern Fort Worth.

Back to Fort Worth

Fort Worth ISD students' open letter against scripted lessons draws more than 900 signatures

Students say slides are often wrong and teachers have no room to teach; Superintendent Peter Licata has defended the Cowtown 12 model and the district did not immediately comment on the letter.

Sasha Esparza

October 6, 20262 min read

Classroom desks and open notebook - illustration, Jake Team LLC

A group signing itself "The Students of Fort Worth ISD" has published an open letter asking the state-run district to loosen the scripted lessons rolled out this school year, and by Tuesday morning more than 900 people had signed it online, the Fort Worth Star-Telegram reported.

The letter, posted Monday on Change.org and addressed to Superintendent Peter Licata, Gov. Greg Abbott and parents, argues that daily lessons built around district slides leave little room for discovery. "Instead of discovering, we're complying," it says.

What the students describe

The letter lists several complaints:

  • Errors in materials. Students say slides and learning guides often do not match and contain spelling mistakes, translation errors in Spanish, and what one student believed was an AI-generated image in a French lesson.
  • Partial books. In one English class reading "Don Quixote," students say they read some chapters, skip others and work from summaries.
  • Classroom rules and walkthroughs. The letter describes timers, posters telling students how to sit when district visitors arrive, and observers with clipboards that leave teachers visibly stressed.

The students ask district leaders to give teachers room to use their own judgment. According to the Star-Telegram, signers range from second graders to seniors, the group met after school and on weekends to write the letter, and the idea grew out of a conversation with City Council member Elizabeth Beck, who suggested an open letter.

The Star-Telegram also reported finding AI-generated images with errors in approved elementary lesson materials it reviewed.

The district's position

A Fort Worth ISD spokesperson did not immediately respond to the newspaper's request for comment.

Licata and the state-appointed Board of Managers adopted the Cowtown 12 instructional model over the summer, under which teachers deliver common lessons. Higher-rated campuses were given more flexibility, while lower-rated schools must follow the model closely.

Licata has said most complaints come from a small number of campuses and defended the results at a Sept. 26 board workshop, though other board members disagreed with him there, the Star-Telegram reported.

Scripted curriculum was the top concern raised at the district's recent community listening sessions, according to the district. The letter names Mayor Mattie Parker, state Sen. Taylor Rehmet, board chair Pete Geren, Licata and the full Board of Managers as the officials the students hope will read it.

Sources

Fort Worth Star-Telegram

change.org

CBS News

Share

Sasha Esparza

Sasha Esparza writes about community life, schools, public safety, and local events in Fort Worth.

Related Stories

More in Texas