Fort Worth

FortWorthWeekly.news — Western roots. Neighborhood news for modern Fort Worth.

Local business? Support local news on FortWorthWeekly.news

Back to Sport

Jake Arrieta’s Hall Ballot Puts His Extraordinary Peak on Trial

The former TCU pitcher’s 2015 season was historic. His 115 wins and 1,612 1/3 innings make the Hall question considerably harder.

Pierce Nash· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

November 17, 20264 min read

For 88 one-third innings in the second half of 2015, Jake Arrieta allowed runs at a 0.41 ERA. That performance can pull the rest of his career into its shadow.

The former TCU pitcher is now on the 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot, and his candidacy turns that shadow into the central question: how much should one towering peak carry when the full career is shorter and less consistent than the usual starting-pitcher résumé?

Arrieta was among 14 newcomers named Monday to the ballot, which includes 27 candidates overall. He is eligible for consideration, not elected to anything; induction requires at least 75 percent of the vote. The results are scheduled for Jan. 19, 2027.

For Fort Worth, the name arrives with a natural TCU connection: Arrieta pitched for the Horned Frogs in 2006 and 2007 before his career took him from an uneven beginning in Baltimore to the front of Chicago’s rotation.

The 2015 season is more than a convenient highlight. Arrieta went 22-6 with a 1.77 ERA, 236 strikeouts and 229 innings for the Cubs. He won the National League Cy Young Award, handled a substantial workload and held the Dodgers hitless on Aug. 30.

Then came the second-half run, when opposing hitters encountered a pitcher who seemed to have removed the usual escape routes from an at-bat.

That year did not appear from nowhere. In 2014, Arrieta went 10-5 with a 2.53 ERA, 167 strikeouts and 156 2/3 innings. He followed the Cy Young campaign with an 18-8 record, a 3.10 ERA, 190 strikeouts and 197 1/3 innings in 2016.

Chicago won the World Series that fall, and Arrieta won both of his starts. He also threw another no-hitter, against Cincinnati, in April of that season.

Taken together, 2014 through 2016 form a serious argument. Arrieta was not a lightly used pitcher who happened to collect one dazzling award. He gave Chicago innings, prevented runs and worked at the center of a championship rotation. His best stretch combined peak performance with the kind of workload that makes a dominant season harder to dismiss as a short burst.

The trouble for his candidacy is what surrounds those three seasons. Arrieta finished with 115 wins, 1,433 strikeouts and a 3.98 ERA across 1,612 1/3 innings and 279 starts. That is a substantial major-league career. It is also a comparatively modest foundation for a starting pitcher seeking a plaque, especially when the ordinary years are not quietly excellent but plainly uneven.

His first three seasons with Baltimore ended with ERAs of 4.66, 5.05 and 6.20. The transformation in Chicago was dramatic, but so was the retreat afterward. His ERA climbed to 3.53 in 2017, 3.96 with Philadelphia in 2018 and 4.64 in 2019.

The shortened 2020 season brought a 5.08 ERA in nine starts. In 2021, his final major-league season, he posted a 7.39 ERA over 98 2/3 innings while splitting time between the Cubs and Padres.

Those seasons do not cancel the Cy Young. They explain why the award cannot settle the Hall discussion by itself. Arrieta’s peak was high enough to stand beside almost any pitcher’s best individual season, yet his career did not supply a long runway before it or enough strong seasons afterward to make that peak merely one part of a larger body of work.

There is also a temptation to let the 115 wins decide the matter in the other direction. That would be too blunt. Win totals depend on run support and team context, and Arrieta’s 2015 season remains historically impressive even without the record.

The more revealing measures are the combination of 229 innings, a 1.77 ERA and 236 strikeouts, followed by another heavy season in 2016. Those are the seasons a voter must weigh, not wave away.

But the opposite shortcut is just as weak. A breathtaking summit does not automatically create a mountain range. Arrieta’s case asks voters to decide whether three elite seasons, one of them extraordinary, outweigh a career that ended with 115 wins and 1,612 1/3 innings.

For TCU, this is a proud baseball connection and a complicated Hall case. Arrieta’s 2015 season deserves enduring recognition as one of the best peaks of his era. The ballot asks a harder question than whether he was once great. It asks whether that greatness lasted long enough to define the career.

Sources

National Baseball Hall of Fame: new2027 ballot announcement

National Baseball Hall of Fame: candidate eligibility and prior vote shares

MLB: Monday ballot announcement

MLB: Jake Arrieta career and season records

MLB: Jake Arrieta biography

TCU: Arrieta CyYoung and university connection

Share

Pierce Nash· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

Pierce Nash covers Fort Worth high school and area college sports.

Related Stories

Sport

Chris Jimerson’s College Test Gets Longer at Tulane

Chris Jimerson Jr. scored through the air and on the ground in North Texas’ loss at UTSA. Tuesday’s starting announcement gives the Fort Worth native a full game to be judged as a quarterback rather than an emergency substitute.

Pierce NashNovember 18, 20264 min read
Sport

Prescott’s Five Touchdowns Met a Defense That Needed More

Dak Prescott’s late brilliance kept Dallas in range, but his third-quarter interception opened a 90-yard San Francisco drive that exposed why the Cowboys needed an almost perfect offensive afternoon.

Pierce NashNovember 16, 20263 min read
Sport

TCU Won the Plain Way Kansas State Couldn’t Stop

TCU’s 20–10 victory over Kansas State in Fort Worth rested on run defense, clean possession and steady third-down work, with a second-half touchdown and a timely field goal stopping the Wildcats’ rally.

Pierce NashNovember 15, 20264 min read

More in Weather